Commons:Monuments database/Duplicate IDs

This page contains an overview of Duplicate IDs encountered in lists of monuments. These are monument identifiers which appear more than once across the source lists for a given country-language combination. Duplicate IDs are often an indication of copy-paste errors, merged lists, or monuments that have inadvertently been listed twice. All the pages and the statistics are updated on a regular basis by a bot based on the data in the monuments database.

How does it work?

Every night a ErfgoedBot updates the Monuments database with all the lists we have on Wikipedia. While harvesting the monument data, the bot tracks every monument ID it encounters for a given country-language combination. If the same ID appears more than once — whether on the same page or across different pages — it is flagged as a duplicate and reported on the duplicate IDs page, along with a count and links to the source pages where it was found.

How can you help?

Go to the duplicate IDs page (linked below). You'll see a table listing each duplicate monument ID, how many times it occurs and on which pages.

For each duplicate, open the linked source pages and look for the repeated ID. There are a few common scenarios:

  • Copy-paste error: A monument was accidentally duplicated when editing the list. Simply remove the duplicate entry.
  • Typo in the ID: Two different monuments were given the same ID by mistake. Correct the erroneous ID to the right value.
  • Genuinely shared ID: In rare cases the same monument may legitimately appear on multiple list pages (e.g. when a list has been split by region). If the duplication is intentional and correct, no action is needed — but consider whether the lists should be reorganised to avoid confusion.

After you fix a duplicate, the next time ErfgoedBot harvests that list (probably tonight) the entry will be removed from the report.

How can I localise the instructions?

Since the duplicate ID reports are overwritten by ErfgoedBot each time the list is updated you cannot add instructions (or categories) directly to the page. To solve this the /header sub-page is automatically included at the top of the page, if it exists. Thus to add instructions for volunteers in your own language simply create the /header sub-page with the required information.

To localise the message used when there are no more duplicate IDs, simply create a /done sub-page with the desired message.

Overview

country lang Total duplicate IDs Total occurrences Total pages with duplicates Report page Row template
ad ca 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ad (ca) Filera BIC And
ae en 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ae (en) UAEmonument row
al sq 1 2 1 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments al (sq) Rreshti Monumentet në Shqipëri
am hy 174 351 69 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments am (hy) Հուշարձան ցանկ
aq en 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments aq (en) Antarctic Protected Area row
ar es 5 26 7 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ar (es) MonumentoArgentina
at de 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments at (de) Denkmalliste Österreich Tabellenzeile
az az 10 20 8 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments az (az) AZE Monument row
be-bru nl 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments be-bru (nl) Tabelrij erfgoed Brussels Hoofdstedelijk Gewest
be-vlg en 141 417 18 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments be-vlg (en) Table row BE
be-vlg fr 9062 28617 351 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments be-vlg (fr) Ligne de tableau MH-Fla
be-vlg nl 334 690 76 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments be-vlg (nl) Tabelrij erfgoed Vlaanderen
be-wal en 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments be-wal (en) Table row Wallonia
be-wal fr 120 240 25 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments be-wal (fr) Ligne de tableau MH-Wal
be-wal nl 1 2 1 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments be-wal (nl) Tabelrij erfgoed Wallonië
bo es 9 20 7 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments bo (es) MonumentoBolivia
by be-tarask 5 10 6 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments by (be-tarask) Вікі любіць славутасьці/Элемэнт сьпісу
ca fr 99 204 45 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ca (fr) Ligne de tableau LPC
ca-fed en 44 108 23 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ca-fed (en) HPC row
ca-muni en 6 12 8 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ca-muni (en) HPC row
ca-prov en 5 10 6 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ca-prov (en) HPC row
ch de 27 54 37 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ch (de) Denkmalliste Schweiz Tabellenzeile
ch fr 13 27 6 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ch (fr) Ligne de tableau Monuments (Suisse)
ch it 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ch (it) Riga della tabella dei beni culturali (Svizzera)
ch-old en 5 10 6 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ch-old (en) SIoCPoNaRS row
ch2 de 2084 14808 557 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ch2 (de) Denkmalliste2 Schweiz Tabellenzeile
ch3 de 119 272 36 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ch3 (de) Denkmalliste2 Schweiz-ZH Tabellenzeile
cl es 48 457 17 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments cl (es) MonumentoChile
cm fr 1 2 1 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments cm (fr) Monument Cameroun ligne
cn en 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments cn (en) NHS China row
co es 2 4 3 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments co (es) MonumentoColombia
cz cs 135 315 145 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments cz (cs) Památky v Česku
de-by de 1392 3933 394 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments de-by (de) Denkmalliste Bayern Tabellenzeile
de-he de 478 1195 180 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments de-he (de) Denkmalliste Hessen Tabellenzeile
de-hh de 61 141 40 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments de-hh (de) Denkmalliste Hamburg Tabellenzeile
de-nrw-bm de 1 3 1 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments de-nrw-bm (de) Denkmalliste Bergheim Tabellenzeile
de-nrw-k de 222 628 53 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments de-nrw-k (de) Denkmalliste Köln Tabellenzeile
dk-bygning da 6 12 6 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments dk-bygninger (da) Tabelrække FBB
dk-fortids da 4373 10012 97 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments dk-fortidsminder (da) Tabelrække FF
dz ar 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments dz (ar) صف معلم الجزائر
ee et 11 22 15 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ee (et) KRR rida
eg ar 8 27 2 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments eg (ar) صف معلم مصر
es ca 7 14 4 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments es (ca) Filera BIC
es es 5529 13406 142 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments es (es) Fila BIC
es-ct ca 2225 4466 459 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments es-ct (ca) Filera IPA
es-gl gl 1 2 2 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments es-gl (gl) BIC
es-vc ca 4 8 5 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments es-vc (ca) Filera BIC Val
fr ca 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments fr (ca) Filera MH
fr fr 2789 5941 382 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments fr (fr) Ligne de tableau MH
fr-object fr 22 71 4 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments fr-object (fr) Ligne de tableau objet MH
gb-eng en 168 340 104 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments gb-eng (en) EH listed building row
gb-nir en 3 6 4 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments gb-nir (en) NIEA listed building row
gb-sct en 3524 7092 772 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments gb-sct (en) HS listed building row
gb-wls en 21 42 4 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments gb-wls (en) Cadw listed building row
ge ka 380 1202 54 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ge (ka) GEO Monument row
gh en 3 6 1 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments gh (en) Ghana Monument row
hk en 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments hk (en) HK Declared Monument row
hr hr 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments hr (hr) Spomenik red
hu hu 6 12 6 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments hu (hu) Műemlék
ie en 26 97 13 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ie (en) NMI list item
il he 1265 7023 120 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments il (he) אתר מורשת בישראל בשורה
il-npa he 61 160 4 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments il-npa (he) יצירת אמנות במרחב הציבורי בישראל בשורה
in en 82 164 6 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments in (en) ASI Monument row
in-com commons 51 102 36 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments in-com (en) India heritage list row
iq ar 2 6 1 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments iq (ar) صف معلم العراق
ir fa 448 901 25 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ir (fa) ردیف یادمان ایران
it it 4 8 3 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments it (it) WLM2015-riga
it-88 ca 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments it-88 (ca) Filera BC Sard
it-bz de 1 2 2 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments it-bz (de) Denkmalliste Südtirol Tabellenzeile
jo ar 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments jo (ar) معلم الأردن
jp-nhs en 18 37 19 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments jp-nhs (en) NHS Japan row
ke en 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ke (en) Kenya Monument row
lu lb 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments lu (lb) Nationale Monumenter row
mt de 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments mt (de) Denkmalliste Malta Tabellenzeile
mx es 131 281 25 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments mx (es) MonumentoMéxico
my commons 36 72 2 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments my (en) Wiki Loves Monuments in Malaysia/Monuments/row
ng en 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ng (en) Nigeria listed historic sites item
nl nl 975 1953 138 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments nl (nl) Tabelrij rijksmonument
nl-aw en 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments nl-aw (en) Table row Aruba monuments
nl-aw nl 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments nl-aw (nl) Tabelrij monument Aruba
nl-gem nl 500 1669 116 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments nl-gem (nl) Tabelrij gemeentelijk monument
nl-prov nl 3 6 2 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments nl-prov (nl) Tabelrij provinciaal monument
no no 44 90 28 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments no (no) Kulturminner row
np en 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments np (en) Nepal Monument row
pa es 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments pa (es) Fila PCN
pe es 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments pe (es) MonumentoPerú
ph en 45 90 4 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ph (en) Philippine cultural property row
pk en 7 14 4 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments pk (en) PKmonument row
pl pl 40 2231 454 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments pl (pl) Zabytki/wpis
pt pt 28 57 10 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments pt (pt) IGESPAR/linha
ro ro 340 688 20 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ro (ro) ElementLMI
rs sr 120 257 22 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments rs (sr) Споменици ред
ru ru 1 17 1 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ru (ru) Monument
se-arbetsl sv 2 5 3 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments se-arbetsl (sv) Arbetslivsmuseum
se-bbr sv 8 16 7 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments se-bbr (sv) BBR
se-fornmin sv 17 35 9 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments se-fornmin (sv) FMIS
se-ship sv 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments se-ship (sv) K-fartyg
sk de 12 24 20 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments sk (de) Denkmalliste Slowakei Tabellenzeile
sk sk 24 51 27 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments sk (sk) Monuments tableline-SK
sv es 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments sv (es) MonumentoElSalvador
th th 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments th (th) แถวโบราณสถาน
tn fr 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments tn (fr) Ligne de tableau monument Tunisie
ua uk 19 47 33 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ua (uk) ВЛП-рядок
ug en 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ug (en) National Cultural Site of Uganda row
us en 4729 9950 1602 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments us (en) NRHP row
us-ca en 182 365 30 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments us-ca (en) CHL row
uy es 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments uy (es) MonumentoUruguay
ve es 42 121 3 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments ve (es) MonumentoVenezuela
wlpa-at de 4 8 6 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/wlpa at (de) WLPA-AT-Zeile
wlpa-es-ct ca 38 76 3 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/wlpa es-ct (ca) Filera art públic
wlpa-fi fi 0 0 0 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/wlpa fi (fi) Wlpa-teokset-rivi
wlpa-il en 6 12 1 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/wlpa il (en) Public art in Israel - row
xk sq 24 50 1 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments xk (sq) Rreshti Monumentet në Kosovë
za en 24 49 7 Monuments database/Duplicate IDs/monuments za (en) SAHRA heritage site row
43043 121993 6997
Category:Commons:Monuments database Category:Commons:Monuments database Category:Commons:Monuments database/Duplicate IDs#*
Category:Commons:Monuments database Category:Commons:Monuments database/Duplicate IDs