User:Basvb/nosource
Explanation
I checked the images in Category:Media without a source as of 15 October 2016 nominated by User:Jcb as well as the files tagged with no source at 15 October by Jcb, but already converted to a DR. From the total of 38 images in Category:Media without a source as of 15 October 2016 24 were tagged by Jcb (see below), an additional 13 were already transformed to a DR or consensus was reached to keep them, totalling at 37 tags. From these 13-14 or 35% has a source provided on the file (but in the wrong place). 9 files (24%) were clearly ok, which could be found out only from their file description. 19 further images would have been better suited for a deletion request, which likely will result in keeping some additional files. Only for 9 files (24%) i agree with the use of the no-source template, 2 of those are very likely (and recent) copyvios, 4 of those are with the same issue from the same user. Note that all these evaluations/comments are personal and others could well disagree for individual cases or structurally with my comments. Also note that some of these files are amongst the most difficult cases with multiple issues combined (which makes me argue for DR's). Also note that I put in an average of 4-5 minutes to investigate files after somebody already looked at them, investing so much time for all images is not something that I expect to be reasonable. Basvb (talk) 19:21, 19 October 2016 (UTC)
Files in Media without a source as of 15 October 2016
| filename | Source indicated? | Comments | What tag applies? |
|---|---|---|---|
| File:Kanowna II.JPG | No | Clearly taken before 1955 and as such PD | Clearly OK |
| File:Kansas counties map.png | No | Pd-USgov claim, as a map it is likely kansas gov work, but indeed needs a source, widely used thus DR to get some attention is not a bad idea | no-source |
| File:Kansas State Seal.png | Yes | The seal indicates a 1861 work and a PD-usgov claim is present, also a source (although vague link) is provided, complicated situation | Needs DR |
| File:Kaple Janov.JPG | No | Exif data and license imply own work. | Needs DR |
| File:Kapliczka w Lisowie.JPG | No | Own work can be implied from license and is very likely, uploader later added the source | Ask active uploader whether he forgot something/DR |
| File:Kaptensgatan tram stop 001.jpg | Yes | Template errors hiding source field | Clearly OK |
| File:78thABWestmoreland.jpg | yes | Source is given, discussion on correctness of source/author can be held in DR | Needs DR |
| File:79th armoured division badge.jpg | No/PD-reasoning is given | UK military insigne, reasoning on it being PD is given | Needs DR |
| File:Kanon 02.jpg | No | Context (template) makes clear that this is supposed to be own work, however looks like a derivative. | Preferably DR |
| File:Kanowna I.JPG | No | Clearly taken before 1955 and as such PD | Clearly OK |
| File:Plata de la barcena.JPG, File:Sadss1.jpg, File:Plata de la Barcena.png and File:PlatadelaBarcena.JPG | No | four coats of arms by the same user, all own work claims, need some information on where their details came from | no source tags |
| File:Saddam surveys al-Qādisiyyah.gif | No | No indication of the source/date is an issue here | No source |
| File:Sagiri.jpg | Yes | Broken source link available (wayback helps) | Needs DR for author/license proof |
| File:Sagrestia Vecchia Filippo Brunelleschi.jpg | Yes | (Doubtful) own work claim | Needs DR |
| File:Sahil khan.jpg | No | Run of the mill webgrab (suspicion) | no-source/copyvio |
| File:Saikung-PositionWithinHKSAR.jpg | Yes | Explanation on creation is given | Needs DR |
| File:Sailfishandtaney.jpg | No | Google gave me the author | Needs DR |
| File:Sailing patin.PNG | No | Could be PD-simple, own work implied | DR to see if PD-simple |
| File:The Erik Sentinel Program 2014-06-20 16-59.jpg | No | Recent file with valid concerns | no-source (no-permission now) |
| File:Saint Anna Church.png | No | circa 1900s image, needs PD consideration | Needs DR |
| File:Saint John of Sviatohirsk.jpg | No | circa 1900s image, needs PD consideration | Needs DR |
Already converted to DR (by others)
| filename | Source indicated? | Comments | What tag applies? |
|---|---|---|---|
| File:7thBN5thADDUI.jpg | Yes | Although sourcing is a bit vague/strangely formatted it is there, military insigne making Pd-gov not unlikely | Needs DR |
| File:Saint thomas d aquin.jpg | Yes | middle ages image, clearly PD-old | Clearly OK |
| File:Saint PopeTelesphorus.jpg | Yes | Clearly Pd-old | Clearly OK |
| File:Saint philemon.jpg | No | Has a signature on the bottom, derivative of painting (possible very old, possibly 1960s-80s) | Needs DR |
| File:KapitanIrangaMiklukho-Maklay1915-1918.jpg | No | author and date given -> enough to determine PD | DR/no tags |
| File:Kapel Amelsdorp.jpg | Yes | Source is on the image itself, clearly a postcard | Clearly OK |
| File:Kankomaru.png | No | 19th century image painting -> likely Pd-old | Needs DR |
| File:7th Armored Division.patch.jpg | No | Pd gov patch | Kept after DR |
| File:7pr-f5.jpg | Yes | Clear source indication, doubts about UK vs US work | DR/Ok, consensus for keep. |
| File:77th Fighter Squadron F-84Gs RAF Wethersfield.jpg | Yes | source in description | Clearly Ok |
| File:72champs.png | Yes (in old version) | author agrees with deletion | not a source but copyvio issue |
| File:SahihMuslimTurkiya.jpg | No | 1300s image | Clearly very old/PD |
| File:Sahihmuslimkoprulu.jpg | No | 1300s image | Clearly very old/PD |
